US President Donald Trump said on Monday that transgender issues were in mess and he aims to protect the country after a report that his administration was considering defining gender as male or female based on genitalia at birth drew widespread condemnation.
“We have a lot of different concepts right now. They have a lot of different things happening with respect to transgender right now,” Trump said amid a protest outside the White House and outpouring of criticism on social media about the proposal.
A proposal initially reported by the New York Times on Sunday, stated that the Trump administration would narrow the definition of gender to male or female at birth and it would be unchangeable later in life.
The move would entail removing recognition of and protections for transgender people under U.S. civil rights laws promoted by the prior administration of President Barack Obama in health care, schools and the military.
About 1.4 million US adults currently identify as transgender, according to a 2016 estimate by the Williams Institute, a research center at UCLA Law School focused on sexual orientation and gender identity law and public policy.
The reported proposal came just a week after New York City created a gender-neutral “X” option for birth certificates, joining California, Oregon, Washington state and New Jersey in offering a third gender category on the government-issued identity documents.
Basing the definition of gender on genitalia at birth is scientifically inaccurate and may harm patients’ health, medical experts said.
Dr Joshua Safer, executive director of Mount Sinai Hospital’s Center for Transgender Medicine and Surgery, said the Trump administration’s definition is “not consistent with current western medicine or science in terms of how we actually operate or define sex of individuals.”
“Sex of individuals is not correlated always with their genitals at birth, or with their chromosomes,” said Safer, who also serves as president of the United States Professional Association for Transgender Health.
The majority of people that are transgender, live with a sense that the gender assigned to them at birth was wrong and decide to transition to the opposite sex, while others live a non-binary or gender-fluid life.
“We urge the administration to ensure all public health policy is firmly rooted in science, and to keep discrimination and political interference out of our nation’s health,” said Dr Lisa Hollier, president of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists.
Doctors also said the new policy would be impossible to apply to “intersex” babies who are born with ambiguous genitalia or reproductive organs.
“Trump’s definition does not even take this entire group of patients into consideration,” said Dr Natasha Bhuyan, a family medicine and LGBT care specialist in Phoenix.
In the case that this is adopted, patients will likely be assigned a male or female sex at birth, which can have devastating long-term psychological and health consequences, she said.